Serves six (and maybe more). You’ll need:
- Penne noodles.
- Heavy cream.
- Whole milk.
- A block of white American cheese.
- A block of Monterey Jack.
- Ground parmesan cheese.
- Ground nutmeg.
- Ground mustard.
- Salt.
- Pepper.
- Panko bread crumbs.
- Parsley.
- Butter.
My wife is a mac and cheese fanatic. If she were trapped on a desert island, the only thing she would take with her is mac and cheese. She is not shy about it. I’m pretty sure she stops people on the street to tell them how awesome a bowl of cheesy noodly goodness would be right about now.
So it didn’t take too long before this cookbook was gifted to us…

…and experimentation began.
The one we like best at the moment is the “City Hall Mac and Cheese,” named for Henry Archer Meer’s restaurant in New York City, which serves their version of this recipe.
They do one thing a little differently than us: they use cayenne pepper. Half a teaspoon of it! A dash is enough to feel the heat, and that much actually makes the dish more spicy than pleasant, so we settled on a more mild, but still zesty, mustard flavor. You can actually get away with mixing in the squirt-bottle mustard you put on a hotdog, but we use ground mustard.

You’re also going to need cheese. Generally we do this with half a pound of white American cheese and half a pound of Monterey Jack. You’ll want to get these as blocks, so you can grate them. The first time you do this at the deli counter of your supermarket, expect to cause confusion. You don’t have to be exact about the measurements, which is good, because you’re likely to come back with way more than half a pound. Most places aren’t used to doing anything but slicing cheese. When you get home, grate up all the cheese into a big bowl and mix it up.

Now we’re really ready to get started! First things first: the noodles.
We use Penne for this instead of macaroni. I can’t imagine using anything else. They have a good size and texture, and they tend to fill up with cheese, making every bite amazing. We just take a whole 1-pound box and boil it according to directions (12 minutes in this case). If the noodles are ready before you need them, that’s okay; they don’t need to be steaming hot. Drain them when they’re al dente and put them aside.

You’re going to need to get some cream on the stove.
Put 2 cups of heavy cream and 2 cups of whole milk in a big saucepan, and get that on medium-high heat. Mix in 1/4 teaspoon of ground nutmeg, and a lot of ground mustard. We probably dump about half that little container in there. Don’t be shy with it. Throw in a little salt and pepper.

Keep stirring this while the sauce reduces down by half. It’ll take about 15 minutes. Don’t leave this alone for too long, as it’ll boil if you don’t keep a close eye on it, and that’s bad. Stir it a lot.
Once it’s reduced, turn the heat down to medium-low and dump in your cheese. You’ll want to keep stirring as you drop it in, so it dissolves into the sauce. Your sauce should be getting thicker now. Take a moment to taste it and adjust your spices if it’s too bland. Then dump the Penne into the sauce and stir it around.

You want to stir this really well, not just to mix it, but to try and get some of the noodle’s starch into the sauce to thicken it more. Don’t beat the noodles up too much, though.
Take this off the heat now and make your topping. This is a good time to preheat the oven to 350, too.
You’re going to want to use panko for this. Panko is just chunky bread crumbs. It’s either right next to the normal bread crumbs in the grocery store, or it’s hidden it in the “ethnic foods” section as some bizarre Japanese thing.

You could probably get away with normal bread crumbs, but trust me, this makes all the difference in the world.
Take a half cup of panko, 2 teaspoons of chopped parsley, and a generous amount of grated parmesan and toss it together.

Now go get a 9x13 baking dish and grease it with some butter. Empty the saucepan of noodles into it.

Stir a little bit of the topping into it now; I find it adds a little more texture to the final dish, but you need to show restraint. Most of that topping should be spread evenly across the top and not mixed in.

Into the oven it goes, 15 minutes.
When it comes out, the top is crispy, but underneath, it’s gooey and creamy and cheesy and irresistable.

You can put this on a plate, if you don’t find yourself eating right out of the dish with a fork.

This pairs really well with a good rotisserie chicken.
This serves a lot of people, especially if it’s a side item and not the main entree. But I should warn you: it doesn’t reheat well, so plan to eat as much as you can as soon as it comes out of the oven.
Experience has shown that most dinner guests fully support such a plan.
Variations:
- Use the squirt bottle mustard. Less seems to go further than the ground mustard, so add it slowly until you get the flavor you want.
- Use different cheeses! There’s a whole world out there, people.























































